Saturday, March 22, 2014

Valentin Silvestrov and what the times dictate

by Peter J. Schmelz

Valentin Silvestrov
Among the almost daily shocks and surprises from the Ukraine has been the active engagement of the Ukrainian pianist/composer Valentin Silvestrov (b. 1937, Kiev). This represents a distinct turnaround from the historical figure I have been studying recently for a book about polystylism in the late USSR: here I look at Silvestrov’s compositions alongside those of Alfred Schnittke from about 1970 through 1991. During this period Silvestrov withdrew from the Soviet dictates for loud, optimistic music into a “quiet” style of composition. Initially it was founded on his own idiosyncratic ideal of “kitsch”: “elegiac and not ironic,” he said. His “kitsch” subsequently morphed in the early 1980s into his idea of a “post” style, a style that would slowly end, ending but never ending: “It is not the end of music as art, but the end of music, in which it may yet remain for a long time.”<1> I have always taken this statement, from a 1990 interview, to be his artistic credo: “I must write what pleases me and not what others like, or what the times dictate, as is often said. Otherwise, it would be a state of affairs … that cripples the imagination. … I must seek beauty.”<2>

Lately, however, the times have been dictating quite a lot to Silvestrov. He apparently went to the Maidan with some frequency during the protests and has composed a series of pieces in response to each new turn of events. “I went to the Maidan, but what could I do?” HERE we find him wrapped in the Ukrainian flag at a memorial event there; as well as two songs he wrote in response to the events of January 18–19, 2014.

The most moving of his recent compositions are two memorials for the protestor Sergey Nigoyan, reportedly the first killed during the shooting in Kiev on January 22, 2014. HERE we see Nigoyan reciting lines from “Caucasus” (Kavkaz) by Ukraine’s beloved poet Taras Shevchenko while standing on the Maidan.  (This year is the bicentenary of Shevchenko’s birth; Nigoyan was Armenian-Ukrainian.)

HERE are the two songs composed and recorded by Silvestrov immediately after Nigoyan’s murder.  The first sets the very same Shevchenko lines read by Nigoyan.<3> It is written in a style reminiscent of Silvestrov’s Quiet Songs (1973–77) and his associated “kitsch” songs (among them the Simple Songs, 1974–81). But its unsettled opening and more agitated delivery also recall the Four Songs to texts by Osip Mandelstam that Silvestrov composed in 1981 and 1982, when he said, “The prison atmosphere at this time depressed us. Eventually it was as if an electric storm hit me, and I had to write something as a sign of protest.”<4> The second of the recent Maidan songs in memory of Nigoyan sets the burial prayer “Lay in rest with the saints” (“Со святими упокой…”). This song is more reserved, a return to the repose of the Quiet Songs. The DIY intimacy of the recordings dominates their affect: vulnerable yet determined, solitary yet meant to circulate on a global stage.

Judging from some local responses to the songs, Silvestrov has managed to capture the grief and hope of the moment. His setting of the Ukrainian hymn (also from late January) “truly were a gift of minutes of peace and support,” as a journalist recently noted.

In this same interview [LISTEN], Silvestrov expressed outrage over the Crimea situation, declaring, “I think that Putin is simply insane!” His statements reveal the tensions and complexities of the situation—the interlinking of Russia and Ukraine, culturally if not politically. Silvestrov distinguishes between the “political face of Russia,” which is says is “entirely covered in excrement,” and its “authentic face”: “Chaikovsky, Lermontov, Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, and the holy Orthodox Church.” He similarly divides Soviet culture, thereby making an explicit parallel between Putin and Stalin, which he amplifies later in the interview. He compares the situation in Crimea to the following: “You invite an acquaintance to your home as a guest, you put him in one of your bedrooms, and then he throws you out of the apartment.” Most interesting to musicologists perhaps will be his praise of the musical qualities of the Ukrainian hymn and his critical comments about the poor musical tastes of the pro-Russian activists in Crimea and the Anti-Maidan demonstrators: “Low, debased music only disgraces the image of Russia. In order to conquer you must have culture.” But as the opening and closing ceremonies of the Olympics in Sochi showed, the Russians are well versed in using “Kul’tura” (with a capital K) as a weapon.

Peter Schmelz is Associate Professor and chair of the Music Department at Washington University in St. Louis.




<1>Sil’vestrov and Frumkis, Sil'vestrov and Tat'yana Frumkis, “Sokhranyat' dostoinstvo. . . ,” Sovetskaya muzïka, no. 4 (1990): 16. 
<2>Quoted in Tatyana Frumkis, liner notes to Valentin Silvestrov, Symphony no. 5, Kitsch Music, etc. Musica Non Grata, BMG/Melodiya CD, 74321 49959 2 (1997), 3 (translation amended by me based on the original Russian in Sil’vestrov and Frumkis, “Sokhranyat' dostoinstvo. . . ,” 12).
<3> Silvestrov had previously set texts by Shevchenko in his Cantata for a cappella chorus (1977) as well as in the Quiet Songs (no. 5, “Proshchay, svite, proshchay, zemle!”). 
<4> Quoted in Frumkis, “Eine lange Reise,” liner notes to Stille Lieder, ECM New Series CD, ECM 1898/99, 982 1424 (2004), 14.

12 comments:

  1. The 2017 Pro Bowl is the National Football League's all-star game for the 2016 season which will be played at Camping World Stadium in Orlando, Florida on January 29, 2017.
    Pro Bowl 2017

    Pro Bowl 2017 Live

    Pro Bowl 2017 Live Stream

    Pro Bowl 2017

    Pro Bowl 2017 Live

    Royal Rumble 2017

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great web site you have got here.. It’s hard to find quality writing like yours these days. I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

    SSC MTS 2017 books

    SSC MTS 2017 syllabus

    SSC MTS 2017 pattern

    ReplyDelete
  3. While the UFC waits for its mainstream stars to return to the octagon, the promotion has booked a UFC 209 card that appeals directly to its. Lando Vannata knew he was ready for the UFC when he got the call last year to face No. 2 ranked lightweight Tony Ferguson on just two.
    UFC 209
    UFC 209 Live , UFC 209 Fight Card
    UFC 209 Live Stream , UFC 209 Fight

    The return of Georges St-Pierre livens up the UFC pay-per-view depth chart. At the time of his 2013 hiatus after a ninth consecutive. Set to take on Marcin Tybura (14-2 MMA, 1-1 UFC) at Saturday's UFC 209, Henrique (10-2 MMA, 2-1 UFC) will have one of his big examples.
    UFC 209
    UFC 209 Live Stream , UFC 209 Live
    UFC 209 Fight , UFC 209 Fight Card

    The return of Georges St-Pierre livens up the UFC pay-per-view depth chart. At the time of his 2013 hiatus after a ninth consecutive ...
    Georges St-Pierre set to fight middleweight champion Michael ...EXCLUSIVE: Georges St-Pierre reveals why he's fighting Michael
    cowboysvsredskinslivestream.net bengalsvssteelerslivestream.co

    ReplyDelete
  4. As the sparkle of March Madness 2017 (NCAA Tournament) ends up being a surging fire, we're sure that you wish to join millions of people to view one of the most exciting college basketball event of the year! Right here's exactly how you could view March Madness 2017 HD 1080p 720p on any one of your gadgets such as iPhone, iPad, Android, Mac/PC, Apple TV, and so on.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    Enjoy March Madness 2017 Live on TELEVISION with Cable
    The simplest method to catch a total amount of 68 groups consisting of to play basketball video games is to view them on a cable with NCAA Tournament membership. Networks broadcasting March Madness 2017 like ESPN, AMC, TNT, TBS, Food Network, Sling TELEVISION, as well as Roku TV will certainly bill $20 monthly without agreement.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    After paying, all clients could appreciate unrestricted live streaming protection throughout the whole males's basketball champion 2017 on TV.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As the shimmer of March Madness 2017 (NCAA Tournament) ends up being a surging fire, we're sure that you intend to sign up with countless people to see one of the most amazing college basketball occasion of the year! Right here's just how you can see March Madness 2017 HD 1080p 720p on any one of your devices such as iPhone, iPad, Android, Mac/PC, Apple TELEVISION, etc.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    Enjoy March Madness 2017 Live on TV with Cable
    The most convenient means to catch an overall of 68 teams including to play basketball games is to watch them on a cable television with NCAA Tournament subscription. Networks broadcasting March Madness 2017 like ESPN, AMC, TNT, TBS, Food Network, Sling TV, and also Roku TV will bill $20 monthly without any contract.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    After paying, all clients can take pleasure in endless live streaming coverage throughout the whole guys's basketball champion 2017 on TV.

    ReplyDelete
  6. ut as Jeremias alluded to, you'd have to go back to 1988 to find an MVP who wasn't on a top-four team; Michael Jordan was in a class of his own that year. There isn't anyone like '88 Jordan this year, so I think it's fair to say the


    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four



    race should be down to players on the true championship-contending teams. Which still somehow leaves six legitimate candidates.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Vermont: Even though a Tar Pumps displaced inside ACC match semifinals, that you had Duke to the basics to get most of the first about half. Justin Jackson, who's developed a good experienced perimeter sport, and then a foul-free Joel Berries II could be the first considerations.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    Certainly, we realize Indicate Several has not made one final Four. That group, stocked by means of talented scorers which will moreover locking mechanism off opponents, can be your partner's primary
    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    When you’re even now in the containment system about this 8-9 sport, or even are seeking your general opinion impression on the Previous Several choices, we’ve gotten everyone covered using a search engine ranking of their 68 squads within the event. It's simple to together with make for you to decide on all those mid-major darlings you’ve already been eyeing to get upset probable.
    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four

    Villanova: The top all around seed. Don't mind the occasional team’s setting with the toughest spot (the Distance, along with matchups vs Duke together with SMU looming), Villanova’s three-man offensive center from Jalen Brunson, Josh Hart in addition to Kris Jenkins has the potential so that you can do it again since indigenous winners.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Two seasons ago, it was an accomplishment to be in the playoffs. Last season, the strides the team made were celebrated. Both seasons ended with a first-round playoff exit. On Wednesday, Avery Bradley said the team didn't even make note of clinching a playoff spot the night before, when the Bulls and Pistons lost while Boston was idle.


    March Madness

    March Madness Live

    March Madness Live Stream

    March Madness 2017

    March Madness 2017 Live

    ncaa March Madness

    ncaa march madness live

    ncaa tournament

    March Madness Bracket

    ncaa final four




    It says a lot about us, that we’re maturing every single day," Bradley said. "Last week, all we did was look at the standings, but we were losing games. We weren’t focused. So we came together as a group and said we can’t worry about where we are. We’ll worry about that when the time is right, where we want to be in the

    ReplyDelete